RASolute 302 4/13 topline (median OS 13.2 vs 6.7 mo, HR 0.40, p<0.0001) reset competitive baselines across the cluster; Plenary detail-reveal is the next forced-disclosure catalyst.
Three external catches plus eleven self-audit corrections against bigbio's own pre-publication ledger. The $5.1B LLY R&D delta is internal-regression discipline, not a Street miss. RVMD Plenary 5/31 (LBA5) is where the daraxonrasib thesis pays — held intact across two stress-test cycles.
The audit track record
Audit's own track record
Three externally verified catches and eleven self-audit corrections — all pre-published. External catches are gaps in how the Street reads the registry; self-audit corrections are internal QC discipline caught before ship. Both shown; neither marketed as the other.
Audit verdict roll-up across 12 RAS-axis tickers
Contradictions caught (10)
LLYfinancials
Contradicted
LLY cash and equivalents $5,282M as of 2026-03-31 (Q1 2026 10-Q).
Implication Material correction needed before Cut B ship. LLY R&D is ~$13B/yr, not ~$8B. Honest framing: pre-publication QC caught an internal aggregation regression against bigbio's own SEC XBRL primary capture.
LLYregulatory
Contradicted
FDA granted Breakthrough Therapy Designation to olomorasib + pembrolizumab on 2025-09-04 for 1L unresectable advanced or metastatic NSCLC with KRAS G12C mutation and PD-L1 >=50%.
“On September 4, 2025, Eli Lilly and Company announced that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has granted Breakthrough Therapy Designation to olomorasib (LY3537982) in combination with pembrolizumab (KEYTRUDA) as a potential first-line treatment for patients with unresectable or metastatic non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) harboring a KRAS G12C mutation and PD-L1 expression >=50%.”
Implication Date precision matters for an audit-grade report. A 7-month discrepancy in BTD timing distorts catalyst-window framing (BTD is ~20 months old, not 6 weeks old). Correct framing: BTD validated > 8 months ago; the 2026-05/06 catalyst is the ASCO 2026 abstract, NOT a fresh BTD.
NVSpipeline
Contradicted
CONTRADICTED by primary source: canonical.yaml lists opnurasib (JDQ443) Phase 3 NSCLC as an active Novartis asset, but Novartis publicly discontinued opnurasib MONOTHERAPY development across all studies in July 2024, including halting the Phase 3 KontRASt-02 trial. Combo dose-...
“Novartis has decided to discontinue development of its experimental KRAS G12C inhibitor opnurasib (JDQ443) across all studies following a strategic review, including halting the Phase III KontRASt-02 trial evaluating the drug in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). 'This decision was made in light of the increasing options available to patients with KRAS G12C-driven cancers,' Novartis told FirstWord in a statement. 'It was not driven by clinical data and no new safety signals have been observe...”
Implication Highest-signal finding. Cut B must restate NVS opnurasib row from Ph3 to Ph1/2 combo and apply combo-PoS. Cluster correlation matrix needs to drop the implied KRAS G12C late-stage NVS competitor — this UNDERSTATES RVMD's competitive moat slightly (one fewer Ph3 G12C competitor...
ROCHpipeline
Contradicted
Genentech terminated its 2021 SHP2-inhibitor collaboration with Relay Therapeutics on 2024-07-11 (notice received; effective 180 days later, approximately 2025-01-07), returning rights to migoprotafib / GDC-1971 / RLY-1971. Termination was 'without cause.' Relay had received a...
“The notice of termination was received by the company on Monday, July 11, 2024, and will take effect 180 days from that date ... Under the terms of the Agreement, the Company received aggregate consideration of $121.8 million from Genentech, including $75.0 million in an upfront payment, $45.0 million in milestone payments as well as reimbursement of certain research and development costs.”
Cut A canonical.yaml and prior workstream referenced the Phase 3 trial as 'ASPyRas'.
“CT.gov v2 API JSON has no 'acronym' field populated for NCT07409272; press release wording is 'first patient has been successfully dosed in the Phase 3 registrational study' with no trial-name acronym.”
Implication Market cap recomputation: 87,856,154 sh × $28.21 = $2.478B (vs erroneous $2.449B at $27.88). EV recomputation: $2.478B - $972.9M net cash = $1.505B (vs $1.476B). | IDYA out-of-cluster scope (mechanism set excludes PKC/Werner/Pol-theta/MAT2A; preserved for traceability).
IDYAcorporate
Contradicted
Market cap on 2026-05-15 ≈ $2.45B (using $27.88 × 87.86M)
“Derived from C-IDYA-MKT-01 (CONTRADICTED) × C-IDYA-MKT-02 (VERIFIED)”
prior corpus[n/a]retrieved 2026-05-18T3
Implication IDYA out-of-cluster scope (mechanism set excludes PKC/Werner/Pol-theta/MAT2A; preserved for traceability).
IDYAcorporate
Contradicted
Enterprise value (mcap minus net cash) ≈ $1.48B as of 2026-05-15
“Derived from C-IDYA-MKT-03 (CONTRADICTED) − C-IDYA-FIN-01 (VERIFIED)”
prior corpus[n/a]retrieved 2026-05-18T3
Implication IDYA out-of-cluster scope (mechanism set excludes PKC/Werner/Pol-theta/MAT2A; preserved for traceability).
IDYAcorporate
Discontinued
IDE275 = Werner Helicase inhibitor; IDEAYA plans to DISCONTINUE development after GSK terminated June-2020 Collaboration Agreement (eff. March 9, 2026); strategic options under evaluation
“IDE275 is a potential first-in-class, oral small molecule inhibitor of the helicase domain of the Werner protein, a RecQ enzyme involved in the maintenance of genome integrity. In December 2025, GSK notified us of its intention to terminate the GSK Collaboration Agreement, which became effective on March 9, 2026. We plan to discontinue development of IDE275 and are currently evaluating strategic options for this asset.”
Implication IDYA out-of-cluster scope (mechanism set excludes PKC/Werner/Pol-theta/MAT2A; preserved for traceability).
Highest-impact ledger corrections (5)
LLYLLY R&D TTM
S-015
$7,926M→$13,045.5M
Self-audit: 39 percent understatement ($5.1B delta) in bigbio's W4 _cluster_summary.json
The $7,926M figure existed only in bigbio's own W4 _cluster_summary.json (internal aggregation error). The Street never published this number. W5 corrected to SEC XBRL primary. Self-audit catch, not Street catch.
Resolution used ACTIVE_NOT_RECRUITING follow-up only + ABSENT from current Novartis pipeline (conservative middle; phase Ph3 preserved per registry; status_note carries narrative truth)
Novartis has decided to discontinue development of its experimental KRAS G12C inhibitor opnurasib (JDQ443) across all studies following a strategic review, including halting the Phase III KontRASt-02 trial (ApexOnco, 2024-07-18; FirstWord quote attributed to Novartis).
Resolution used TERMINATED (corporate disclosure post-dates CT.gov by 2 days and is authoritative on program status). Degrader thesis narrows to setidegrasib (G12D, VHL) + ASP5834 (pan-KRAS).
Astellas has decided to discontinue ASP4396, which used a cereblon E3 ligase, after determining that its data were no better than those it reported for setidegrasib. (Astellas Q3 FY2025 earnings call 2026-02-04, ApexOnco quote)
ASP4396 TERMINATED (Astellas Q3 FY2025 earnings call 2026-02-04: 'data were no better than those it reported for setidegrasib'). Degrader thesis narrows to setidegrasib (G12D, VHL) + ASP5834 (pan-KRAS). ASPyRas trial name does not exist; setidegrasib Ph3 = NCT07409272.
Drop H2 2026 ASP4396 Ph1 readout from forward catalyst tape; sell-side likely still on the old pipeline.
Forward catalyst density 2026-05-15 to 2026-11-15 for ASLN RAS-axis = 0 binary readouts. Potential ASP4396/ASP5834 Ph1 preliminary readouts H2 2026 are low-confidence (no company date guidance issu...
Cluster valuation matrix (_compute_valuation.py) assigns Novartis 2 programs (opnurasib Ph3 + TNO155 Ph1/2 combo) with EV_per_program $150,457M. The 'Ph3' tag on opnurasib is now CONTRADICTED by pr...
Avutometinib FAERS surveillance through 2026-Q1: 19 total individual AE reports; only AST increased meets n>=3 threshold (n=5, ROR 3.773, 95% CI 1.564-9.103, PRR 3.746, IC 1.584, signal flag true)....